MEET

AMY NEUSTADT

FOUNDER OF EVOLV EXEC
As Principal of Evolv Exec, I help leaders succeed and avoid burnout in their first or second year in a new executive-level role, which includes newly promoted managers, new executives, new Executive Directors, leaders inheriting larger teams and business owner expanding their leadership scope (from Founder to CEO).  Research shows 40–60% of new leaders struggle early without targeted transition support, so my coaching focuses on the capabilities that matter most at this stage: strategic thinking, decision-making, communication, team alignment, and executive presence. My work also involves supporting organizations during executive transitions by aligning boards, leaders and teams around clear expectations, sustainable pace and shared accountability.

With more than 20 years of nonprofit, academic, and private-sector organizations including leadership roles at The Lewis Group think tank, the University of Chicago, the University of Colorado’s Addiction Research and Treatment Services program, and Principal of Amy Neustadt Consulting LLC, I’ve helped mentor new leaders as they transition into their role, align strategy with measurable outcomes and grow sustainable organizations.

I hold a master’s degree in public health with a focus in Behavioral Sciences from Emory University, am a Certified Executive Coach through the Center for Executive Coaching, a trained Burnout Coach, and am currently completing my Board-Certified Coach (BCC) and International Coaching Federation (ICF) credential.

My approach is warm, direct, and practical, grounded in research and real-world experience. Having experienced burnout myself, I’m especially committed to helping leaders grow into bigger roles with clarity, confidence, and sustainable performance.

EXECUTIVE COACHING and CONSULTING OFFERED GLOBALLY

Why I STARTED EVOLV Exec

Leadership transitions are one of the highest-risk periods for any organization. After more than two decades working with nonprofit leaders, rising managers, and growing business owners, I saw talented, committed professionals step into bigger roles and struggle—or burn out—within their first 24 months. I kept hearing leaders say:

“I’m still stuck in the weeds.”
“I feel responsible for everything”’
“I got promoted and suddenly everything feels different.”

“There are no clear expectations.”
“I don’t know what I should be doing anymore.” 

It wasn’t because they lacked commitment, skill, or loyalty. The role had changed faster than their leadership identity. The qualities that earned them the role —being hands-on, responsive, and operationally strong—were no longer enough. Success now requires strategic thinking, delegation, executive presence, and building team capacity instead of carrying everything themselves.

Just as often, the organization wasn’t ready either. Expectations were unclear, support structures were thin, and boards or senior teams underestimated the complexity of leadership transitions. Research from organizations like the Center for Creative Leadership and Developmental Dimensions International shows leaders in their first 18–24 months face high stress and minimal transition support. And when a leadership transition fails, replacing an executive can cost 50–200% of their salary once recruitment, lost productivity, and organizational disruption are included.

Effective leadership development programs build both individual capability and relational systems. Our work supports both the leader and the surrounding system so leaders and teams can grow, align, and succeed together. Through coaching and/or consulting, we partner with leaders, boards, and/or teams to clarify priorities, align expectations, strengthen confidence and build the systems that allow leaders to succeed in their new or expanded role sustainably.

At Evolv Exec, our engagements are designed to strengthen leadership, build team capacity, and prevent burnout during this critical transition period.

Together, we focus on:
  • Shifting from tactical execution to strategic leadership.
  • Leading former peers and building accountable teams.
  • Delegating effectively and developing leadership capacity.
  • Aligning boards, senior teams, and new leaders around priorities.
  • Building sustainable leadership habits that scale with the role.
How we work
Clients can work with us in different ways depending on their needs. Engagements may include one or more of the following services:
  • Executive Coaching: 1:1 coaching for leaders in their first 24 months of transition.
  • Team Coaching: Facilitated sessions with the team to align leadership teams and build communication and trust.
  • Group Programs: Cohorts for new Executive Directors, new managers, executives and/or growing business owners to learn with peers.
  • Executive Consulting: Support for organizations onboarding and developing new leaders.
The goal is simple: to help new leaders operate at the level their role requires, with clarity, confidence, and impact.
SCHEDULE A FREE CONSULTATION

HOW I HELP YOU EVOLV